Source Confidence
Check what your sources support before you publish.
A cultural site’s website, an older brochure and a guide’s recent note can give different impressions of when people can visit. Your team needs to establish which information answers the visitor’s question and which conditions still need checking.
Source Confidence is Tamaga’s method for assessing the material behind a travel claim. It helps you choose supported wording, retain important qualifications and identify the next useful check.
Begin with the question the reader needs answered
“Can someone visit this site on Monday?” needs a more precise answer than “Is the site open?”
The answer may depend on independent access, guided visits, the season or a reservation requirement. Write down the question and the intended use before assessing the sources.
The same approach applies to a departure schedule, accommodation condition, partner description or destination claim.
Work out what each source establishes
Consider this fictional cultural-site example:
| Available material | What it supports | What remains unresolved |
|---|---|---|
| The operator’s current timetable lists guided visits Tuesday–Sunday, with advance reservation. | The published schedule and booking condition for guided visits. | Whether independent visits are possible on Monday. |
| A destination brochure from the previous season says “open daily.” | What the brochure communicated for that period. | Whether the statement still applies and which kind of access it described. |
| A guide records finding the gate closed one Monday morning. | An observation at a particular time and entrance. | Whether that closure represents the usual Monday arrangement. |
Before treating these statements as contradictions, check whether they concern the same period, service and conditions.
The timetable may answer the question about guided visits. None of these sources, by itself, establishes the current arrangement for an independent Monday visit.
Examine relevance, responsibility and dates
For each consequential statement, check four things:
- What is being established? Identify the place, service, period and conditions covered by the source. Keep the conclusion within that scope.
- Who can establish it? Identify the person or organization responsible for the fact or decision. A guide can document an observation; the site operator may maintain the visiting arrangements.
- When does it apply? Distinguish when something happened, when the source was published and when you reviewed it. A recent review of an old document does not make its contents current.
- How does it relate to other material? Investigate differences rather than selecting the most confident wording. Several pages repeating one brochure still lead back to that same source.
An official source, field observation or partner document can each be useful. Record why it supports this particular statement.
Turn the assessment into usable wording
For the fictional site, supported wording could be:
The current timetable lists guided visits from Tuesday to Sunday, with advance reservation. For an independent visit on Monday, check the access arrangements with the site operator before planning your visit.
This communicates the established schedule and directs the unresolved question to someone who can answer it.
Where the sources already provide a clear answer, publish that answer with its relevant conditions. Where an important point remains uncertain, narrow the wording or complete the necessary check.
Keep a short record of the conclusion
Retain enough information to explain the editorial decision:
- The claim or question assessed.
- The source and version consulted, with relevant dates.
- What the material supports and any unresolved limitation.
- The wording or action chosen.
- Who will review it again and what change should trigger that review.
One editor can maintain this record. Describing what was checked is more useful than attaching “verified” without an explanation.
The record might say: “Guided-visit schedule supported by the operator’s current timetable; independent Monday access still requires clarification.”
Carry the finding into the places where the claim is reused
Once the wording is supported, use a Claim Ledger to keep it connected with its evidence, responsibility and review trigger across pages, translations and other uses.
If the operator publishes a new timetable, reassess the relevant statement and review the versions that carry it.
For an accommodation-focused research example, the One Hotel, Seven Versions source note explains the basis and limitations of the study’s observations. Its evidence labels belong to that research context.
Bring one claim and the material behind it
Share the statement you want to use, the sources available and the question your audience needs answered. We can discuss what the material supports, where the uncertainty lies and what to check next.